Amazon's Dramatic Showdown: NLRB Judge Rules Against Tech Giant in Epic Union Battle

In a stunning turn of events, a National Labor Relations Board (NLRB) judge has ruled against Amazon, finding the tech giant guilty of multiple violations of federal labor law at its massive JFK8 warehouse in New York. The ruling exposes a dark underbelly of the e-commerce behemoth's tactics, including alleged retaliation against pro-union employees, racial disparagement of organizers, and hiring a "union avoidance" consultant who reportedly called activists "thugs."

The battleground? The Staten Island warehouse known as JFK8, where workers, in a historic move, voted to join the Amazon Labor Union (ALU) in April 2022. Since then, it's been a high-stakes game as the ALU strives to secure a contract with Amazon, setting the stage for a fierce clash between the company and the newly formed union.

The NLRB judge, Lauren Esposito, heard a year's worth of virtual testimonies from Amazon employees, managers, and consultants, unearthing a web of alleged wrongdoing. Among the shocking findings, Esposito determined that Amazon unlawfully confiscated union pamphlets, conducted surveillance on organizing activities, and even retaliated against an employee, Daequan Smith, who supported the union, eventually firing him in November 2021.

Adding more fuel to the fire, Bradley Moss, a "persuader" hired by Amazon as a union avoidance consultant, reportedly threatened employees, deeming it "futile" to join the ALU. Moss allegedly went further, comparing the union drive to a "Black Lives Matter protest about social injustice" and referring to activists as "thugs." These revelations paint a vivid picture of the lengths Amazon allegedly went to dissuade unionization efforts.

As a consequence of this landmark ruling, Amazon faces the obligation to post notices at JFK8 and a neighboring facility, DYY6, reminding workers of their rights. Additionally, the company must compensate Daequan Smith for any loss of earnings and benefits, marking a rare victory for the embattled workforce.

Amazon, known for its contentious relationship with unions, is currently reviewing the judge's decision. Despite expressing disagreement with certain aspects of the ruling, Amazon spokesperson Eileen Hards acknowledged the judge's decision not to reinstate the terminated individual.

This development adds another layer to Amazon's labor woes, as the company confronts 240 open or settled unfair labor practice charges across 26 states, involving allegations ranging from conduct during union elections to overall treatment of its warehouse and delivery workforce. The tech giant's clash with ALU leader Chris Smalls further underscores the ongoing battle between labor and one of the world's most powerful corporations.

In a final twist, Amazon continues to challenge the JFK8 election results, raising the stakes in a saga that highlights the evolving landscape of labor relations in the age of e-commerce giants. As the dust settles, the NLRB ruling serves as a pivotal moment in the ongoing struggle for workers' rights and fair treatment within the Amazon empire.



Amit Bhaskar


Team | AMZ Pro

Amit is the co-founder of AMZPro. He has been helping businesses succeed on Amazon since 2014. He also holds a lot of certifications from Amazon like ATES (Amazon Trained Ecommerce Specialist) & Amazon Ads Expert. He has worked with 100s of small & medium businesses around the world so as to make their Amazon dream come true. He is also a big believer of e-commerce & believes that soon the world will shift to mostly ecomm from mostly retail (brick & mortar stores) as of now. He also loves hiking & off-roading.

Subscribe to Amazon Seller News

We send a free weekly newsletter with the most important news for Amazon sellers. Add email id
above to get in the list.

About AMZPro

We are a Done For You Amazon Agency that has been in operation since 2014. We specialize in scaling Amazon sales for various sellers across all Amazon marketplaces.

Want a Free Audit of Your Amazon Store